Quotessence
Home / Authors / Chris Chambers

Chris Chambers Quotes

Author

Filter quotes by topic

AllPsychologyReplication CrisisScientific MethodologyAcademic PoliticsFraudP HackingReplication

Famous Chris Chambers Quotes

“One recent case highlighted by Dan Simons relates again to the work of Yale psychologist John Bargh. In 2012, Bargh and colleague Idit Shalev published a study claiming that lonelier people prefer warmer baths and showers, thereby compensating for a lack of “social warmth” through physical warmth.44 In 2014, psychologist Brent Donnellan and colleagues reported a failure to replicate this finding—and not just in a single experiment but across nine experiments and more than 3,000 participants, over 30 times the sample size of the original study.45 Despite this failure to replicate, as well as the presence of unexplained anomalies in the original data, Bargh and Shalev refused to retract their original paper. In many other sciences, a false discovery of this magnitude would automatically trigger excision of the original work from the scientific record. In psychology, unreliability is business as usual.”

PsychologyReplicationScientific Methodology
Book:The Seven Deadly Sins of Psychology: A Manifesto for Reforming the Culture of Scientific Practice
Create image

“If we take a science such as experimental physics, where studies tend to have high statistical power, methods are well defined and de facto preregistered, then the failure to reproduce a previous result is considered a major cause for concern. But in a weaker science where lax statistical standards and questionable research practices are the norm, attempts to reproduce prior work will often fail, and it should therefore come as no surprise that retraction is rare.”

PsychologyScientific MethodologyReplication Crisis
Book:The Seven Deadly Sins of Psychology: A Manifesto for Reforming the Culture of Scientific Practice
Create image