Quotessence
Home / Books / Frames of War: When is Life Grievable?

Frames of War: When is Life Grievable?

Book by Judith Butler · 2 quotes · Grievability, War, Life

Filter quotes by topic

AllGrievabilityWarLifePrecariousnessPrecarityDeathViolenceButlerGriefPrecarious LifeAnthropocentrismBeing WithBoundariesDissociationEthicsIndividualismIsraeli Palestinian ConflictKleinLossMedia Manipulation

Frames of War: When is Life Grievable? Quotes

“According to Melanie Klein, we develop moral responses in reaction to questions of survivability. My wager is that Klein is right about that, even as she thwarts her own insight by insisting that it is the ego's survivability that is finally at issue. Why the ego? After all, if my survivability depends on a relation to others, to a "you" or a set of "yous" without whom I cannot exist, then my existence is not mine alone, but is to be found outside myself, in this set of relations that precede and exceed the boundaries of who I am. If I have a boundary at all, or if a boundary can be said to belong to me, it is only because I have become separated from others, and it is only on condition of this separation that I can relate to them at all. So the boundary is a function of the relation, a brokering of difference, a negotiation in which I am bound to you in my separateness. If I seek to preserve your life, it is not only because I seek to preserve my own, but because who "I" am is nothing without your life, and life itself has to be rethought as this complex, passionate, antagonistic, and necessary set of relations to others. I may lose this "you" and any number of particular others, and I may well survive those losses. But that can happen only if I do not lose the possibility of any "you" at all. If I survive, it is only because my life is nothing without the life that exceeds me, that refers to some indexical you, without whom I cannot be.”

LifeLossGriefMoralitySurvivalBoundariesDissociationSelf PreservationSeperationOthernessButlerBeing WithKlein
Book:Frames of War: When is Life Grievable?
Create image

“There is no life without the conditions of life that variably sustain life, and those conditions are pervasively social, establishing not the discrete ontology of the person, but rather the interdependency of persons, involving reproducible and sustaining social relations, and relations to the environment and to non-human forms of life, broadly considered. This mode of social ontology (for which no absolute distinction between social and ecological exists) has concrete implications for how we re-approach the issues of reproductive freedom and anti-war politics. The question is not whether a given being is living or not, nor whether the being in question has the status of a “person”; it is, rather, whether the social conditions of persistence and flourishing are or are not possible. Only with this latter question can we avoid the anthropocentric and liberal individualist presumptions that have derailed such discussions.”

LifeSocialIndividualismPersonhoodAnthropocentrismButlerSocial Ontology
Book:Frames of War: When is Life Grievable?
Create image