Quotessence
Home / Books / Claiming Tribal Identity: The Five Tribes and the Politics of Federal Acknowledgment

Claiming Tribal Identity: The Five Tribes and the Politics of Federal Acknowledgment

Book by Mark Edwin Miller · 4 quotes · Tribes, Native American, Tribal Identity

Filter quotes by topic

AllTribesNative AmericanTribal IdentityBiaBlood QuantumDawes RollsFive TribesNative Americans

Claiming Tribal Identity: The Five Tribes and the Politics of Federal Acknowledgment Quotes

“A host of scholars who have studied surviving southeastern Indian groups conclude that few if any of these peoples possess cultures that do not bear the mark of significant contact with nonindigenous societies. Even the most “traditional,” such as the Seminoles of Florida, whom Nancy O. Lurie describes as “Contact-Traditional,” were significantly altered from precolonial days by the time pioneer “salvage” ethnologists described their cultural traits and created laundry lists that have since become benchmarks for defining aboriginal culture in the region. To many more traditional reservation-based groups, having surviving Indian cultural traits is extremely important to proving authenticity, although they are not required for acknowledgement via the BIA process. The existence of surviving Indian cultural traits is highly persuasive to most observers in proving that a group still exists as a viable tribal community.”

Native AmericanTribesTribal Identity
Book:Claiming Tribal Identity: The Five Tribes and the Politics of Federal Acknowledgment
Create image

“Some tribes maintain blood quantum, such as once-quarter proven blood degree from their tribe. Even so-called purely ‘descendancy’ tribes such as the Five Tribes with no blood quantum requirement jealously guard some proven, documentary link by blood to distant ancestors. More than any single BIA requirement, however, this criterion has proven troublesome for southeastern groups because of its reliance on on-Indian records and the confused (and confusing) nature of surviving documents.”

TribesBlood QuantumDawes Rolls
Book:Claiming Tribal Identity: The Five Tribes and the Politics of Federal Acknowledgment
Create image

“They were ‘half breeds,’ ‘mongrel races,’ and ‘mixed-bloods.” These individuals and families may have gravitated to frontier areas or to mixed-race communities that were more welcoming of their heritage. They too kept traditions of their Indian lineage alive, yet the fact that they assimilated into existing, non-tribal (if also nonwhite) communities leads to the same conclusion as the white-Indian individuals mentioned: it could hardly be said that these mixed Indian, black, and white communities were tribes. Because of stereotypes, however, it is easer to view these impoverished, marginal enclaves as Indian. The basic facts pertinent to tribal recognition are the same: thousands of individuals left tribal communities in the nineteenth century, and their descendants cannot now make a convincing case to be aboringal Indian tribes.”

Native AmericansBiaFive Tribes
Book:Claiming Tribal Identity: The Five Tribes and the Politics of Federal Acknowledgment
Create image