Quotessence
Home / Books / Max Weber and Postmodern Theory: Rationalisation Versus Re-enchantment

Max Weber and Postmodern Theory: Rationalisation Versus Re-enchantment

Book by Nicholas Gane · 4 quotes · Ethics, Morals, Politics

Filter quotes by topic

AllEthicsMoralsPoliticsReligionScienceAutomationBelief Vs KnowledgeBureaucracyEmotional DecisionsFreedomIndividualityInhumanityPoliticiansResponsibility

Max Weber and Postmodern Theory: Rationalisation Versus Re-enchantment Quotes

“Processes of rationalization and disenchantment engender a shift from a social order founded upon value-rational beliefs and governed through charismatic and traditional forms of authority, to an order ruled by the force of instrumental reason and dominated by new forms of institutional bureaucracy. This movement results in the depersonalization of the social world: instrumental calculation steadily suppresses the passionate pursuit of ultimate values, and bureaucracy reduces the scope for individual initiative and personal fulfillment... instrumental reason... is not only tied to the devaluation or disenchantment of the highest and most sublime values and ideals, but places important limits on the scope for individual autonomy and freedom in the modern world.”

ReligionFreedomIndividualityBureaucracy
Book:Max Weber and Postmodern Theory: Rationalisation Versus Re-enchantment
Create image

“... As Weber suggests, once science is employed to justify and enact ideal values, especially through the actions of an elite few (the academy), particular values, in this case the idea of what is 'natural', are cast into an objectively valid and legitimate form, and thus appear as being beyond critique. And at this point Weber rightly warns that science, contrary to Durkheim's belief, is not both cognitive and moral in nature, for it rests upon a designation of authority, and may, especially if used beyond its own limits, give rise to new means of domination.”

ScienceReligionPoliticsEthicsMorals
Book:Max Weber and Postmodern Theory: Rationalisation Versus Re-enchantment
Create image

“In The Inhuman... Lyotard, like Weber, reminds us of the distinction between technological development and 'human' progress. He argues, in particular, that the development of technology, or 'techno-science', is driven by the quest for maximum efficiency and performance, and as such leads to the emergence of new 'inhuman' (technological) forms of control rather than to the emancipation of 'humanity'. Lyotard reasserts the instrumental nature of the modern system, arguing that 'All technology ... is an artefact allowing its users to stock more information, to improve their competence and optimize their performances'. In this view, techno-science may be seen to stand against all instances of the unknown, including the aporia of the future anterior, and thus to have little respect for forms which are different or other to itself. This is compounded by the fact that technological development is intimately connected to the drive for profit. Lyotard proposes that this directs the production of knowledge and conditions the nature of knowledge itself, for information, itself a commodity, is increasingly produced in differentiated, digestible forms ('bits') for ease of mass exchange, transmission and consumption, and with the aim of enabling the optimal performance of the global system.”

ScienceEthicsMoralsInhumanityAutomationBelief Vs Knowledge
Book:Max Weber and Postmodern Theory: Rationalisation Versus Re-enchantment
Create image

“... In view of the violence of political power responsibility must always prevail. The only possible synthesis between conviction and responsibility is thus one in which passion is subordinated to responsibility, so that political responsibility is the primary value to be pursued with passion, thereby engendering what H. H. Bruun terms a 'responsible ethic of conviction.' Weber states: 'To be sure, mere passion, however genuinely felt, is not enough. It does not make a politician, unless passion as devotion to a "cause" also makes responsibility to this cause the guiding star of action.”

PoliticsResponsibilityPoliticiansEmotional Decisions
Book:Max Weber and Postmodern Theory: Rationalisation Versus Re-enchantment
Create image