“Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms on pernicious anemia yet explains their supposed remission by Shirley’s being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur for those 9 years. But Dr. Wilbur never diagnosed a dissociative disorder in 1945. Nathan does not seem to recognize the implausibility of Dr. Wilbur creating via suggestion a complex dissociative disorder in five sessions, particularly when the doctor herself did not diagnose it. Nathan attributes Shirley’s postintegration improvement in functioning to being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur rather than to the therapy. But the pernicious anemia continued to be undiagnosed and untreated during that time period, so any symptoms due to it should have continued rather than showing an improvement that coincided with psychotherapy with Dr. Wilbur. Debbie Nathan’s thesis is self-contradictory.”
Quote by Colin A. Ross
Author
You May Also Like
“The glorious presence of God is with us. Let us rise in mighty strength to build the nation.”
Source: Think Great: Be Great!
“I am responsible for the world, as I am the world, the world is me.”
“World leeches masquerading as world leaders, would sell their mothers if the price is right.”
Source: Visvavatan: 100 Demilitarization Sonnets
Source: Yaralardan Yangın Doğar: Explorers of Night are Emperors of Dawn
Source: Visvavatan: 100 Demilitarization Sonnets
Source: Visvavatan: 100 Demilitarization Sonnets
Source: Visvavatan: 100 Demilitarization Sonnets