Home / Topics / South African Law Quotes

South African Law Quotes

Browse 10 quotes about South African Law.

South African Law Quotes

“The bad parts of the statute are not judicially severable, I consider, from the rest of its provisions that deal with imprisonment. Their roots are entangled too tenaciously in the surrounding soil for a clean extraction to be feasible. The conclusion to which I accordingly come is that we are left with no option but to declare those provisions as a whole to be constitutionally invalid on account of their objectionable overbreadth.”

Law Metaphor South Africa Imprisonment Constitutional Law South African Law Severability

Author:John Didcott

“If the good is not dependent on the bad and can be separated from it, one gives effect to the good that remains after the separation if it still gives effect to the main objective.”

Law South Africa Constitutional Law South African Law Severability

Author:Johann Kriegler

“Severability is an important concept in the context of the relations between this Court and Parliament; like 'reading down', it is an instrument of judicial restraint which reduces the danger of producing an overbroad judicial reaction to overbroad legislation.”

Law South Africa Constitutional Law South African Law Severability Reading Down

Author:Albie Sachs

“In the criminal law [...] imprisonment should be resorted to only after the most anxious consideration.”

Law Human Rights South Africa Imprisonment Criminal Law Constitutional Law South African Law South African Criminal Law

Author:Pius Langa

“Imprisonment is the form of punishment which may detrimentally affect not only the offender but also his family and his employment and because of its duration it can seldom be kept from becoming general public knowledge. It [...] can have a lasting demoralising effect on the character and personality of the offender. The loss of liberty, tedium, regimentation [...] which prison life entails, have a greater potentiality than a whipping for destroying the offender's self-esteem and the integrity of his character and for changing, for the worse, his way of life.”

Law Liberty Family Self Esteem Human Rights Punishment Employment South Africa Imprisonment South African Law

Author:P.W. Thirion

“The views of the Courts in regard to imprisonment have however undergone modification in the last ten years. Imprisonment is seen more and more as a harsh and drastic punishment to be reserved for callous and impenitent characters. We wish to adopt a more enlightened approach in which the probable effect of incarceration upon the life of the accused person and those near to her is carefully weighed.”

Law Human Rights South Africa Imprisonment South African Law

Author:V.G. Hiemstra

“The difference between the past and the present is that individual freedom and security no longer fall to be protected solely through the D vehicle of common-law maxims and presumptions which may be altered or repealed by statute, but are now protected by entrenched constitutional provisions which neither the Legislature nor the Executive may abridge. It would accordingly be improper for us to hold constitutional a system which, as Sachs J has noted, confers on creditors the power to consign the person of an impecunious debtor to prison at will and without the interposition at the crucial time of a judicial officer.”

Law Freedom History Security Human Rights Credit Debt South Africa Imprisonment Common Law Constitutional Law South African Law Albie Sachs Constitution Of South Africa

Author:Pius Langa

“My conclusions, on this point, are as follows: when the Law Commission says committal of judgment debtors is an anomaly that cannot be justified and should be abolished; when it is common cause that there is a general international move away from imprisonment for civil debt, of which the present committal proceedings are an adapted relic; when such imprisonment has been abolished in South Africa, save for its contested form as contempt of court in the magistrate's court; when the clauses concerned have already been interpreted by the Courts as restrictively as possible, without their constitutionally offensive core being eviscerated; when other tried and tested methods exist for recovery of debt from those in a position to pay; when the violation of the fundamental right to personal freedom is manifest, and the procedures used must inevitably possess a summary character if they are to be economically worthwhile to the creditor, then the very institution of civil imprisonment, however it may be described and however well directed its procedures might be, in itself must be regarded as highly questionable and not a compelling claimant for survival.”

Law Freedom Human Rights Debt South Africa South African Law Foreign Law Civil Imprisonment Legal Interpretation

Author:Albie Sachs

“Plainly it is not every error made by a witness which affects his credibility. In each case the trier of fact has to make an evaluation; taking into account such matters as the nature of the contradictions, their number and importance, and their bearing on other parts of the witness's evidence.”

Law Evidence Contradiction Credibility Witnesses South African Law 1982

Author:H.C. Nicholas

“Never mock a sin of mine until you have walked a mile in my moccasins”

Poetry South African Law Aparthied Neil Gevisser

Book:The Tyranny Of Trust

Source: The Tyranny Of Trust