Quotessence
Home / Books / The Open Society and Its Enemies - Volume One: The Spell of Plato

The Open Society and Its Enemies - Volume One: The Spell of Plato

Book by Karl Popper · 4 quotes · Platonism, Totalitarianism, Plato

Filter quotes by topic

AllPlatonismTotalitarianismPlatoClass WarfareCollectivismAnti IndividualismPolitical PhilosophyMarxismNationalismState OppressionAnti Democratic ThoughtAuthoritarianismCaste SystemFar RightPoliticsRousseauRuling ClassTyrannyAlienationAltruism

The Open Society and Its Enemies - Volume One: The Spell of Plato Quotes

“It is clear that spiritual naturalism can be used to defend any ‘positive’, i.e. existing, norm. For it can always be argued that these norms would not be in force if they did not express some traits of human nature. [...] In fact, this form of naturalism is so wide and so vague that it may be used to defend anything. There is nothing that has ever occurred to man which could not be claimed to be ‘natural’; for if it were not in his nature, how could it have occurred to him? Looking back at this brief survey, we may perhaps discern two main tendencies which stand in the way of adopting a critical dualism. The first is a general tendency towards monism, that is to say, towards the reduction of norms to facts. The second lies deeper, and it possibly forms the background of the first. It is based upon our fear of admitting to ourselves that the responsibility for our ethical decisions is entirely ours and cannot be shifted to anybody else; neither to God, nor to nature, nor to society, nor to history. All these ethical theories attempt to find somebody, or perhaps some argument, to take the burden from us. But we cannot shirk this responsibility. Whatever authority we may accept, it is we who accept it. We only deceive ourselves if we do not realize this simple point.”

ResponsibilityHuman NatureEthicsPolitical PhilosophyMoral PhilosophyNature Vs NurtureMonismAvoiding ResponsibilitySpiritual NaturalismEthical Theories
Book:The Open Society and Its Enemies - Volume One: The Spell of Plato
Create image

“The internal disunion of human nature, the schism of the soul, leads to the schism of the ruling class. And as with Heraclitus, war, class war, is the father and promoter of all change, and of the history of man, which is nothing but the history of the breakdown of society. We see that Plato’s idealist historicism ultimately rests not upon a spiritual, but upon a biological basis; it rests upon a kind of meta-biology of the race of men. Plato was not only a naturalist who proffered a biological theory of the state, he was also the first to proffer a biological and racial theory of social dynamics, of political history.”

PoliticsRacismPlatoPolitical PhilosophyTotalitarianismAuthoritarianismFar RightPlatonismRacial TheoryIdealist Historicism
Book:The Open Society and Its Enemies - Volume One: The Spell of Plato
Create image

“At the same time, the reader is led to identify individualism with the views of Thrasymachus, and to think that Plato, in his fight against it, is fighting against all the subversive and nihilistic tendencies of his time. But we should not allow ourselves to be frightened by an individualist bogy such as Thrasymachus (there is a great similarity between his portrait and the modern collectivist bogy of ‘bolshevism’) into accepting another more real and more dangerous because less obvious form of barbarism. For Plato replaces Thrasymachus’ doctrine that the individual’s might is right by the equally barbaric doctrine that right is everything that furthers the stability and the might of the state.”

NationalismIndividualismPolitical PhilosophyTotalitarianismCollectivismPlatonismAnti IndividualismAnti Democratic ThoughtState Oppression
Book:The Open Society and Its Enemies - Volume One: The Spell of Plato
Create image

“This ground-plan, conceived by a great architect, exhibits a fundamental metaphysical dualism in Plato’s thought. [...] In politics, it is the opposition between the one collective, the state, which may attain perfection and autarchy, and the great mass of the people—the many individuals, the particular men who must remain imperfect and dependent, and whose particularity is to be suppressed for the sake of the unity of the state (see the next chapter). And this whole dualist philosophy, I believe, originated from the urgent wish to explain the contrast between the vision of an ideal society, and the hateful actual state of affairs in the social field—the contrast between a stable society, and a society in the process of revolution.”

IdealismPlatoSocial ChangeConservatismPolitical PhilosophyAuthoritarianismCollectivismPlatonismImmutabilityAutarchy
Book:The Open Society and Its Enemies - Volume One: The Spell of Plato
Create image