Quotessence
Home / Authors / Rebecca Goldstein Books
Rebecca Goldstein

Rebecca Goldstein Books

Novelist

Related Quotes

“When we call a philosopher distinguished, we are not saying that she is worthy and not saying that she is recognized, but we are saying that she occupies the intersection of both – that she is recognized and worthy; even that she is recognized because she's worthy. In the case of arate, the direction of the "because" can seem a little vaguer, so that it can sometimes seem almost as if someone is regarded as worthy because they are recognized.”

FameRegardRecognition
Book:Plato at the Googleplex: Why Philosophy Won't Go Away
Create image

“It's deplorable that academia should prostitute itself, but there it is. Not even Harvard is above it. In fact, Harvard least of all, with that ludicrous delusion of self-importance that makes every Harvard professor feel he's a public intellectual, qualified to comment on issues far beyond his expertise.”

PhilosophyPowerNovelIntellectualEthicsPhilosopherAcademicStatus QuoAcademiaAcademics
Book:36 Arguments for the Existence of God: A Work of Fiction
Create image

“Quite often we are led to aporia, an impasse, unable to proceed a step further. Socrates is almost always there, but even he is only a supporting character. The starring role is given to the philosophical question. It is the philosophical question that is supposed to take center stage, cracking us open to an entirely new variety of experience.”

HumilityOpenness
Book:Plato at the Googleplex: Why Philosophy Won't Go Away
Create image

“...Plato conceived of philosophy as necessarily gregarious rather than solitary. The exposure of presumptions is best done in company, the more argumentative the better. This is why discussion around the table is so essential. This is why philosophy must be argumentative. It proceeds by way of arguments, and the arguments are argued over. Everything is aired in the bracing dialectic wind stirred by many clashing viewpoints. Only in this way can intuitions that have their source in societal or personal idiosyncrasies be exposed and questioned. ... There can be nothing like "Well, that's what I was brought up to believe," or "I just feel that it's right," or "I am privy to an authoritative voice whispering in my ear," or "I'm demonstrably smarter than all of you, so just accept that I know better here." The discussion around the seminar table countenances only the sorts of arguments and considerations that can, in principle, make a claim on everyone who signs on to the project of reason: appealing to, evaluating, and being persuaded by reasons. (pp. 38-39)”

DiscussionArgumentsReasonsArgumentative
Book:Plato at the Googleplex: Why Philosophy Won't Go Away
Create image

“So Socrates was a kind of gadfly. He was a sort of philosophical urban gorilla hanging around in the middle of Athens, asking these peculiar questions of everybody - important people, young men, slaves - questions that had to do with ultimately what's the life that's worth living. And Plato was one of the young men who hung around him, a very aristocratic young man, came from a very old, important family.”

PeopleMenKindImportantYoungMiddlePhilosophicalAskingSlaveYoung ManPeculiarHungUrbanPlatoWorth LivingAthensGorillasHanging AroundAristocraticGadflies
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“Are there experts, ethical experts, that's very offensive to all of us? Because it's part of our humanity to have a stake in these questions to feel that we ourselves know the difference between right and wrong. And then along come these experts, philosophers, claiming, you know, an expertise, a special training, a special skill, a special talent.”

KnowsFeelsHumanityDifferencesSpecialTalentSkillsTrainingPhilosopherExpertsEthicalStakesOffensiveExpertiseSpecial Talents
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“One of the interesting things about the ancient Greeks is that they really didn't have our conception of individual rights. They didn't have our conception of all lives matters. And it was really was true for them, that certain lives matter a lot more than others. It didn't dawn on them that all lives, although different, can be lives of equal mattering. And that is actually something a huge ethical lesson.”

DifferentMatterCertainIndividualInterestingRightsHugeLessonsEqualAncientDawnGreekEthicalConceptionInteresting ThingsIndividual RightsAncient Greek
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“Everybody have equal rights to a life of full flourishing. Philosophy slowly, slowly has given us arguments saying, look, you already committed to your own life flourishing, and you're being inconsistent if you don't expand it. So philosophy often works in trying to show us that there's an inner incoherence in our points of view. We're all committed to one thing when it comes to us and our own kind, but we're not willing to expand it and we're guilty of inconsistency.”

IfsTryingLooksKindPhilosophyShowsGivenViewsRightsOne ThingWillingEqualArgumentCommittedPoint Of ViewGuiltyEqual RightsInconsistentFlourishingInconsistencyIncoherence
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“Our society is falling back increasingly on rampant consumerism and self-promoting social media as a way for people to feel that their lives matter - self-centered means of numbing the questions of mattering. Culture has relapsed back into the self-aggrandizing, glorifying answers that the Athenians had presumed, which had Socrates railing against them until he got so annoying that they killed him.”

PeopleWayFeelsMeanSelfMatterFallCultureSocialAnswersMediaSocial MediaOur SocietyAnnoyingConsumerismPromotingSelf CenteredNumbingAthenians
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“I think one reason is that philosophers are more insecure to speak accessibly because non-philosophers are skeptical that philosophers have any special expertise. After all, all people - not just philosophers - have attitudes and points of view on various philosophical questions, and they rather resent being told that there are professionals who can think about these things better.”

PeopleThinkingReasonSpeakViewsAttitudeSpecialPhilosophicalPhilosopherVariousPoint Of ViewInsecureSkepticalExpertiseResentPhilosophical Questions
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“I would say to anybody who thinks that all the problems in philosophy can be translated into empirically verifiable answers - whether it be a Lawrence Krauss thinking that physics is rendering philosophy obsolete or a Sam Harris thinking that neuroscience is rendering moral philosophy obsolete - that it takes an awful lot of philosophy - philosophy of science in the first case, moral philosophy in the second - even to demonstrate the relevance of these empirical sciences.”

ThinkingFirstsPhilosophyProblemAnswersMoralCasesPhysicsAwfulNeuroscienceRelevanceObsoleteRenderingPhilosophy Of ScienceMoral Philosophy
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“I like that there are so many different ways of looking at the world and I like all of the particular narratives. In any case we will never all see the same way on these [religious] issues. It's the way liberals and conservatives will never see the same way on individuals whereas it’s different orientations and they go too deep down and when we're dealing with questions that can't be definitively answered by science that's where you're sort of... your orientation swells in to fill up the gaps and so we're never always going to agree.”

WorldWayDifferentIndividualReligiousCasesIssuesParticularAgreeNarrativeDifferent WaysGapsOrientation
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“Does God have a reason for wanting us to be charitable, to take care of those who can't take care of themselves? Either God does or God doesn't, it's just logic. If God has a reason then there is a reason independent of God and whatever God's reason is we should figure it out for ourselves. There is a reason and God doesn't really ground morality at all. God wants us to give charity because it's the right thing to do.”

IfsWantGivingShouldDoeReasonCareFiguresMoralityLogicIndependentCharityTake CareThings To DoRight ThingWant UCharitable
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“God doesn't help. I think that's a knockdown argument. I think that it really shows that whatever moral knowledge we have and whatever moral progress we make in our knowledge or whatever progress we make in our moral knowledge is not coming really from religion. It's coming from the very hard work really of moral philosophy, of trying to ground our moral reasonings.”

ThinkingTryingHardPhilosophyHelpingShowsMoralProgressHard WorkArgumentReasoningMoral PhilosophyMoral Reasoning
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image

“It was while I was studying philosophy that I came to understand. . . that it is no sign of moral or spiritual strength to believe that for which one has no evidence, neither a priori evidence as in math, nor a posteriori evidence as in science. . . . It's a violation almost immoral in its transgressiveness to shirk the responsibilities of rationality.”

BelievePhilosophySpiritualResponsibilityMoralStudyEvidenceMathRationalityImmoralViolationShirkSpiritual StrengthStudying Philosophy
Author:Rebecca Goldstein
Create image